From Valentine’s Rush to Repair Revenue: Don’t Miss the Follow-Ups

From Valentine’s Rush to Repair Revenue: Don’t Miss the Follow-Ups

Valentine’s Day is the Super Bowl of sparkle. The boxes are opened, the selfies are posted, and your store gets that familiar glow of “we crushed it.”

And then—quietly, politely, and usually starting 48–72 hours later—the real wave arrives:

• “It’s gorgeous… can we resize it?”
• “I love it… but can you tighten the stone?”
• “He got me a watch… can you size the bracelet?”
• “Do you do battery replacement?”

If your Valentine’s rush was the sale, these are the follow-ups that become steady, high-margin service revenue—and they’re also the moments that turn first-time buyers into “my jeweler” customers.

Here’s the thing most retailers don’t fully cash in on: repairs are not a side quest. They’re a profit center. Many stores see repairs account for 10–25% of total revenue (often 15% on average), and rings + watches can make up a big chunk of that repair mix.

So today, let’s talk about how to turn the post-Valentine’s “quick fixes” into real repair revenue—without turning your counter into a crime scene of sticky notes, mystery bags, and “Who took the ring sizing form?”

Before you move ahead, if you'd like to upgrade your jewelry & watch repair software, try Luxare. Contact us here or book a demo directly.
‍

The post-Valentine’s follow-up trifecta (aka: the predictable money)

1) Post-purchase resizing
Surprise jewelry gifts are romantic. Surprise ring sizing is… ambitious.

Ring resizing is one of the most common repair-category requests, and it’s often the first “service touchpoint” a new customer has with your store. Nail this experience—speed, clarity, communication—and you’re not just resizing a ring. You’re resizing their loyalty.

2) Stone tightening / prong checks
New rings and daily life meet fast. Customers may not say “prong integrity,” but they will say: “It feels like it’s catching on my sweater.”

Industry coverage has noted that a large share of service-counter repair work tends to cluster around the classics—ring shanks, prongs, and chains—which is exactly why you want a consistent intake + inspection routine.

3) Watch servicing after gifting
Watches are a Valentine’s favorite—especially for milestone gifting. And watch follow-ups show up quickly: sizing, strap swaps, battery checks, water-resistance questions, and basic servicing. Jewelers who treat watch service as a real offering (not a reluctant add-on) can turn it into a repeat traffic engine. This trio is predictable. Which means your process should be, too.

The repair revenue reality (and why it’s so underrated)

Most retailers think of revenue as “what sells out of the case.” But repair revenue is special because it tends to be:

• Steadier year-round than big-ticket merchandise sales
• Repeat-driven (once you earn trust, they keep coming back)
• High-intent foot traffic (they walk in already wanting something)
• A gateway to add-on sales (cleaning, upgrades, anniversary gifts, warranty conversations)

Benchmarks vary by store, but one widely-circulated industry breakdown pegs repair services at 10–25% of store revenue (avg ~15%), with common repair tickets often landing in the tens of dollars to low hundreds, and meaningful volume for independents.

Even better: repairs aren’t just revenue—they’re retention. When you handle someone’s engagement ring or daily watch well, you stop being a store and become a relationship.

The difference between “we do repairs” and “we run repairs”

You can offer repairs and still leak money.

The leaks usually come from:

• unclear estimates
• mismatched expectations
• missed updates
• delayed approvals
• “where is that piece?”
• inconsistent documentation
• staff spending 10 minutes per customer just reconstructing the story

That’s not a craftsmanship problem. That’s a workflow problem. The stores that win repairs don’t necessarily have the fanciest bench. They have the cleanest process.

The post-Valentine’s repair playbook (that keeps your counter sane)

Here are the practical moves that protect margin, reduce rework, and keep customers happy—especially in the weeks after Valentine’s.

1) Treat repair intake like a sales moment (because it is)

A repair intake is the most trust-heavy interaction you’ll have—sometimes more than the original sale. The customer is handing you something emotionally loaded. Your job is to make them feel:

• it’s safe
• it’s understood
• it’s documented
• it’s moving forward

Stuller (a major industry supplier) has long emphasized that improving the repair take-in process is a straightforward lever for growing service—and it’s not hard to see why: intake is where clarity and trust are created (or lost).

Make intake consistent:

• photo the item (front/back, any damage, hallmarks if needed)
• record metal type + stone details (as observed)
• capture “customer-stated issue” vs “store-observed issue”
• confirm deadlines (realistic ones)
• clearly note what’s included and what’s extra

If you want fewer disputes later, you need better inputs now.

2) Build a “Repair Bundle” mindset (not one-off fixes)

Here’s an easy revenue unlock: most repair walk-ins have more than one need.

Example:

• resizing request → also needs stone tightening → also could use cleaning/polish
• clasp repair → chain wear check → preventative soldering recommendation
• watch sizing → strap upgrade opportunity → quick service check

A classic industry point: prongs, shanks, and chains represent a large share of common repair work at the counter—yet many jewelers miss additional issues because they don’t check consistently.

So add one simple rule: Every repair gets a 60-second “health check.” Then you offer options, not pressure.

3) Turnaround time is your secret competitive advantage

Customers aren’t always shopping for the lowest repair price.

They’re shopping for:

• confidence
• clarity
• speed
• “I don’t have to chase you for updates”

The post-Valentine’s Day period is especially time-sensitive because customers want the gift to feel “perfect” quickly. If your turnaround time is vague, they’ll feel uneasy. If it’s predictable, they’ll relax.

Best practice:

• give a realistic range (e.g., “5–7 business days”)
• send updates at key steps (received → in progress → awaiting approval → ready)

Repairs are operational. Customers judge you on operations.

4) Price with confidence (and document the why)

A common repair mistake: underpricing because it “feels small.”

But your pricing needs to cover:

• labor
• handling
• intake/admin time
• risk
• communication time
• vendor coordination (if outsourced)

One rule of thumb cited in industry-focused guidance is that retailers often mark up bench labor to ensure profitability—commonly multiples of the jeweler’s fee depending on complexity and overhead.

You don’t have to copy anyone’s pricing. But you do need:

• a pricing framework
• consistency
• documentation that backs it up

Because the only thing worse than an unhappy customer is an unhappy customer who says: “But last time you charged me less,” and you have no record.

5) Don’t let approvals become the bottleneck

Approvals kill repair velocity.

They often look like:

• staff calling customers repeatedly
• voicemail tag
• unclear cost breakdown
• “I’ll check and call you back” loops

The fix: standardize your estimate format (and send it fast).

A good estimate includes:

• what you’re doing
• why it’s needed
• timeframe
• total price
• what happens if you find something else mid-repair

Customers say yes faster when the decision is simple.

What your customers actually want (and won’t always say)

They want:

• visibility (what’s happening)
• confidence (it’s being handled properly)
• control (approve costs before you proceed)
• convenience (minimal back-and-forth)

They do not want:

• hunting for paper receipts
• inconsistent updates
• “We can’t find it, but it’s here somewhere”
• unexpected charges at pickup

In 2026, the customer experience bar is set by Amazon and Uber, not by “local shops.” That doesn’t mean you need to be robotic. It means you need to be organized.

The real Valentine’s opportunity: a repair-driven retention loop

If you do repairs well, you create a cycle:

1. Customer comes in for a fix
2. You handle it smoothly + communicate well
3. They trust you with more valuable items
4. They buy gifts from you because you “take care of things”
5. They refer friends because you’re reliable

This is how repair becomes marketing—without paying for ads.

Where Luxare fits: Repair for retailers, built for the real world

If your repair process currently lives across:

• spreadsheets
• paper envelopes
• photos in someone’s phone
• customer notes in a POS “misc field”
• and a prayer

…you’re not alone. But you’re also leaving money on the table.

Luxare’s Repair for Retailers is designed to make repairs:

• trackable
• standardized
• fast to intake
• easy to update
• easy to approve
• easy to deliver

So you can:

• capture every detail at intake (and reduce disputes)
• keep a clean chain-of-custody
• standardize estimates and approvals
• automate customer updates (without chasing)
• track turnaround times, vendor performance, and repair profitability
• turn repairs into a repeatable system—not a daily scramble

Because the post-Valentine’s rush isn’t the problem. The chaos is.

Quick FAQ (because customers will ask—and your team should be ready)

What is the repair revenue for a jewelry store?
Many stores see repairs contribute around 10–25% of revenue (often 15% average) depending on business model, service mix, and operational maturity.

What repairs drive the most volume?
Common counter work often centers on rings and chains—especially prongs/shanks/chains—as well as watch battery/sizing/service requests.

When is repair demand highest?
Repairs spike around gifting seasons (like Valentine’s) because follow-ups (fit, tightening, sizing, servicing) arrive shortly after gifts are given.

The punchline: Valentine’s didn’t end on February 14

Valentine’s Day creates a surge of brand-new customers walking into your store—often for the first time. The follow-ups are where you prove you’re worth returning to.

So don’t treat resizing, tightening, and watch servicing like small stuff. That “small stuff” is:

• repeat revenue
• reputation
• retention
• and the easiest reason for customers to keep choosing you

If you want the post-Valentine’s wave to turn into a year-round service engine, your next best move isn’t another promotion. It’s a better repair workflow. Try Luxare.

‍

That's something we can help you do. Contact us here to understand more about our repair for retailers offering. You can also book a demo here.